California’s billionaire tax – fair share or costly gamble?
In November, Californians will vote on ballot measure Proposition 40, which proposes a one-time, 5% tax on wealth exceeding $1 billion.
What’s new: At a recent event hosted by the economics department at the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences, two economists debated which way voters should go.
- In opposition: Matthew Kahn, provost professor of economics and spatial sciences at USC Dornsife
- In support: Emmanuel Saez, professor of economics at the University of California, Berkeley
David Schönholzer, assistant professor of economics at USC Dornsife, moderated the event.
Problem: Federal funding cuts could leave California with a multibillion-dollar funding gap for its Medicaid programs, known as Medi-Cal. This may cause many low-income residents to lose their coverage.
The big picture: Saez said California’s billionaires have accumulated enormous wealth that current income tax laws largely fail to address.
- “My view is that billionaires have gone tax free and should pay their fair share,” he says.
He estimated Prop. 40 could raise at least $100 billion over five years; money that could cover Medi-Cal funding gaps.
Yes, but: The revenue is projected to run out in a few years, leaving lawmakers and voters in the same position again. It’s signaling that this may not be a one-time measure, says Kahn.
High-income residents and entrepreneurs could move away to avoid repeated wealth taxes, reducing the state’s income tax base.
- “I unfortunately believe that Prop 40 will make us poorer as a state,” he says.
Go deeper: California should instead treat the loss of federal funding as an opportunity to reprioritize and make existing programs more efficient, Kahn says, not just replace the money with a new tax.
Between the lines: Medicaid, says Saez, is already a cost-effective program that pays providers less per patient than other forms of health coverage. Greater efficiency alone also cannot replace the enormous scale of the lost federal funding, he adds.
What to watch: Even if voters approve Prop. 40, two other measures on the ballot may make enacting it an uphill battle.
- Prop. 41: Requires audits of programs supported by new special taxes, such as Prop. 40. It also forces the revenue to be included within California’s spending limit, potentially preventing it from being used to fund primarily healthcare.
- Prop. 42: Prohibits new state taxes on financial assets and other personal property while restricting retroactive taxation, both key elements of Prop. 40.
These are “essentially the poison pills to kill Proposition 40,” says Schönholzer.
The bottom line: If passed, Prop. 40 would be the first wealth tax of its kind in the nation. Kahn and Saez agree that Californians are voting on more than just a new tax in November; they’re also choosing whether to participate in a great economic experiment.