Octopus Got Your Tongue?
A USC Dornsife linguist and marine biologist join forces in a National Science Foundation study that uses octopuses to shed light on speech disorders such as those associated with Parkinson’s disease.
It’s an unusual coupling: A linguist and a marine biologist are working together to investigate the human tongue. In their study, the USC Dornsife researchers are using two species of octopus and tiny worms that helped win a Nobel Prize.
The work is funded by a three-year grant from the National Science Foundation, and the investigators will use facilities at the USC Wrigley Marine Science Center on Catalina Island for some of their research.
The research is funded through an NSF program called INSPIRE (Integrated NSF Support Promoting Interdisciplinary Research and Education) that “is intended to encourage investigators to submit bold, exceptional proposals.”
The project at USC Dornsife certainly fits that description.
“Most people are surprised by this combination of linguistics and biology,” said Khalil Iskarous, assistant professor of linguistics and a principal investigator on the NSF grant.
The project will compare the movement of the tongue to the movements of the arms of the octopus and the body of a very small and thoroughly studied worm known as C. elegans. All three muscular systems work without bones that function as rigid “levers.” Hydrostatic, their function is based on the resistance of fluids to compression. Squeezing water in one part of a muscle exerts pressure on water in other parts of the muscle forcing it to move.
“The hydrostatic principle is the common denominator for these three systems,” Iskarous said. “For the worm, it’s for locomotion; for the octopus, it’s for manipulation; for the tongue, it’s for communication and speech.”
Iskarous will work with a USC Wrigley Institute faculty member, Andrew Gracey, associate professor of biological sciences and a co-principal investigator on the grant. Gracey will examine the nematode worm C. elegans and the connection between the worm’s proteins and its neurons to determine the connection between its genetics and its behavior. A third researcher on the project — the lead octopus expert — is Jennifer Mather, professor of psychology at the University of Lethbridge in Alberta, Canada.
Each limb of an octopus can perform so many manipulations it seems to have infinite degrees of freedom. Here, an octopus moves underwater in video taken by Jean Alupay, soon-to-be a postdoctoral researcher at USC Dornsife.
USC Dornsife’s Khalil Iskarous is comparing octopus arm movements with movements of the human tongue, seen here in a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) movie taken by the USC Speech Production and Articulation Knowledge Group led by Professor Shri Narayanan [http://sail.usc.edu/span].
C. elegans has served as an “experimental workhorse” since the 1970s, and it was used in genetic research that led to the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2002. (One of the Nobel laureates, Sydney Brenner, honored C. elegans as “Nature’s Gift to Science” in the title of his Nobel lecture.) C. elegans is a nematode, part of a phylum of worms found in nearly every ecosystem, from the tropics to the poles, from the lowest elevation to the highest, and it measures one millimeter end-to-end.
Iskarous described C. elegans as a “simple complex organism,” adding that decades of research have documented the characteristics of every one of its cells.
“We know the number of neurons in C. elegans; we know the connectivity between every neuron and every other neuron, and we know which neuron cells are connected to muscle cells,” Iskarous said. “If you know the neural layout and the neuromuscular layout, you have a chance at formulating simple mathematical ideas that are linked to movements of the organism and can be measured.”
The NSF project will develop algorithms and geometric analyses to create “numerical descriptors” for movements of C. elegans under a variety of conditions, including mutations to its genes. Gracey said gene mutations often have obvious impacts on the worm’s movements and coordination, and the numerical descriptors might be used to quantify the effects of different genes in C. elegans on movement. The same process might be used to describe the role of genetics in the movement of octopus arms and the human tongue.
Iskarous and Gracey will study the worm’s use of dopamine, a chemical released by nerve cells to send signals to other nerve cells. Iskarous wants to look for connections between dopamine signals in C. elegans to linguistic problems in humans, specifically the speech disorders associated with Parkinson’s disease. Parkinson’s is a cellular deficiency in the basal ganglia, a part of the brain that makes dopamine, and scientists are using C. elegans in studies of this degenerative disease. Iskarous will examine how the degeneration of cells that produce dopamine affect speech, especially through impacts on the flexibility of the tongue. Before arriving at USC Dornsife in 2011, Iskarous pursued this line of research at Haskins Laboratories in New Haven, Connecticut.
In the search for rules that govern hydrostatic muscular systems, the project will examine one of the most versatile systems of all — the arm of the octopus. Each of its eight limbs can adopt so many configurations and perform so many manipulations that it seems to have “infinite degrees of freedom,” Mather said.
Mather and a postdoctoral researcher will participate in the USC Dornsife project, including work with two species of octopus that live in the waters around Catalina Island.
Mather said each octopus arm has extraordinarily complex sets of muscles, and the animal can use some of them as a “skeleton” for support while other muscles contract.
“An octopus can extend or contract its arm, bend it anywhere along its length and twist as much as it likes,” Mather said. “Theoretically, it can make a knot in its arm and run the knot down its length and off the tip.
“But there must be rules for how they can move,” Mather continued. “For example, there must be different rules to run a muscle system that has no fixed skeleton, like the octopus, from the rules that run for a muscle system with a fixed skeleton.”
Mather is an ethologist — an expert in animal behavior — and she has been studying and writing about the octopus and other cephalopods since 1978. She will help Iskarous and Gracey search for similarities between the octopus’ manipulation of its arms with the movement and function of the human tongue.
Another octopus biologist, Jean Alupay, will join the research team in January 2014. Alupay is finishing a Ph.D. at the University of California, Berkeley Department of Integrative Biology, and will work as a USC Dornsife postdoctoral researcher on the USC University Park campus and at the Wrigley Marine Science Center on Catalina Island.
The research team will study octopus behavior in the wild and in captivity at the USC Wrigley Marine Science Center on Catalina Island. Alupay said the research team is interested in two closely related species — Octopus bimaculoides and Octopus bimaculatus — found around Catalina Island and throughout the northeastern Pacific Ocean.
“We hope to base most of our study of their natural behavior on field observations using scuba diving, snorkeling and video recordings by collaborators,” Alupay said.
Iskarous has studied how the tongue is affected by Parkinson’s disease as well as how tongue movements differ according to influences of age, dialect and language. (Two years ago, he studied speech by young French-speakers in Montreal as a Distinguished Fulbright Visiting Chair at McGill University.)
“The human tongue is a very different muscular system than the rest of the human body,” Iskarous said. “Our bodies are vertebrate mechanisms that operate by muscle working on bone to move. The tongue is in a different muscular family, much like an invertebrate. It’s entirely muscle — it’s muscle moving muscle.”
Human speech is the result of a complex orchestration and timing of the tongue, the palette, the teeth and the lips. Degeneration of the brain cells that produce dopamine disrupts this orchestration and causes problems with motor control of the tongue, a condition known as dysarthria.
The NSF research will explore the promise of C. elegans as a model for the dysarthria caused by Parkinson’s disease. Dopamine synthesis and uptake in C. elegans will be manipulated to model the abnormal dopamine signaling in people with Parkinson’s disease.
“The degeneration of cells that produce this chemical neurotransmitter, dopamine, have effects on behavior,” Iskarous said. “C. elegans doesn’t have a brain or basal ganglia, but some of its cells use dopamine in a way similar to mammals. With the worms, we can manipulate dopamine in much finer ways than is possible in more complex organisms, and we may have a chance to understand more complex connectivity in an animal like an octopus or a human being.”
Finding a Common Language
This project was among the first awards that NSF announced last year through the INSPIRE program. Gracey said one of the challenges they face with this interdisciplinary work is developing a vocabulary that connects linguistics to the movement of organisms such as the octopus and the worm.
“Linguists have a way of describing speech,” Gracey said. “They have a nomenclature, a system of annotation for describing speech — how the tongue moves, how the palate moves, how the lips move — so when they describe the way different sounds are made, they have a standard vocabulary. There isn’t a similar structured vocabulary for octopus movements. In addition, we’re trying to find a mathematical way to describe the worm’s movement which we can then directly apply to these other movements by the octopus arm and the human tongue.
“It’s a real challenge to compare multiple systems, and this has been a challenge in biology for a long time,” Gracey said. “You don’t have to do this if you’re going to work on one organism, but if you’re working on more than one organism you need to be speaking the same language and be using the same types of descriptors. We’re still scratching the surface on this — it’s a very complicated project.”
Related News Items
- Octopus Video Aids Linguists October 1, 2015
- High-tech Greenhouse August 5, 2015
- Shark Week Indebted to More Than Sharks July 6, 2015
- In Memoriam: Basil Nafpaktitis, 85 July 1, 2015
- Spread the Word May 12, 2015
- In Memoriam: Katrina J. Edwards, 46 October 29, 2014
- A Scientific Hot SPOT September 25, 2014
- Heidelberg Steers the Ship September 15, 2014
- Chilton Wins Marine Award September 10, 2014
- In Memoriam: Gerald Bakus, 79 August 21, 2014
- A Pearl of a Job August 19, 2014
- Estebanico’s Turn to Speak July 29, 2014
- Digital Humanities at Its Finest June 27, 2014
- Knot a Problem May 27, 2014
- Early CAREER Award May 27, 2014
- Our Dazzling Doctorates May 15, 2014
- The Brain Is a ‘Prediction Machine’ April 30, 2014
- In Memoriam: James Higginbotham, 72 April 28, 2014
- No Loss For Words January 15, 2014
- Dissolving Away Confusion January 9, 2014